Book Review: Great Big Beautiful Life

Title: Great Big Beautiful Life
Author: Emily Henry
Length: 432 pages
Genre: Contemporary Fiction / Romance
Plot Summary: Two competing biographers — an optimistic magazine writer and a brooding investigative journalist — find themselves unexpectedly vying for the exclusive rights to tell the life story of Margaret Ives, a reclusive former tabloid princess and heiress living on a quiet southern island. As long-buried secrets surface and personal narratives collide, the rivalry between the two writers begins to shift, forcing them to navigate their intense professional friction and examine whether the stories they tell about themselves are as true as the ones they write for others.
Review: The main flaw of this book is that its central romance — the dynamic taking up the majority of the page count — is the story element I cared about the least. Emily Henry is undoubtedly a good writer, and her beautiful prose kept me flipping the pages. However, I simply couldn’t invest in the supposed once-in-a-lifetime love story between Alice and Hayden. Instead, I found myself far more captivated by Margaret’s history and the precarious, complex bond between Alice and her mother.
My disconnect from Alice and Hayden largely stems from the execution of their intimacy: whenever their conversations turned deep, right at the threshold where a genuine intellectual and emotional connection could blossom, the narrative hastily detoured to sex. The sheer quantity of these scenes felt unnecessary to the progression of their relationship. Throwing in acts of lust while trying to sell a profound, true love built in the span of just a couple of weeks simply fell flat.
Having read two of Henry’s previous novels, I knew not to expect high stakes. Her works are typically grounded in realism (which I respect), though that realism often borders on boring. I usually turn to her stories when I want something lighthearted that won’t make me eye-roll. However, this will likely be my last Henry novel and perhaps my last romance novel overall.
Ultimately, this genre just isn’t my cup of tea, but not because I’m unromantic (I consider myself a romantic at heart). I simply require real heart within the romance: true love that shines not only between two characters, but within each of their individual journeys of personal growth. Without that deeper emotional core, a romance fails to leave an impact.
Rating: 3/5
