Book Review: The Midnight Library

Title: The Midnight Library
Author: Matt Haig
Length: 304 pages
Genre: Fiction

Plot Summary: Somewhere between life and death stands a mysterious library where the shelves stretch on infinitely, filled with books that offer a chance to undo life’s biggest regrets. Faced with overwhelming despair and a sense of absolute failure, Nora Seed finds herself transported to this purgatorial realm run by her former school librarian. Each book in the library allows Nora to step into an alternate version of her life to explore paths where she pursued different careers, stayed with former partners, or fulfilled childhood dreams. As she travels through countless parallel existences to find the “perfect” life, Nora must confront her deeply rooted regrets before time runs out and the library dissolves forever.

Review: At first, I felt the scope of this book was too broad and deep, yet the actual exploration of its themes proved far too superficial and brief. I felt his brevity works against the central thesis of the novel. But upon reaching the ending, I felt the core message was much too simple and this book easily could have been an essay instead.

At the start, I felt terribly sad for Nora as a character who had lost all hope and wanted to end her life. However, as she explored the endless variations of her potential lives courtesy of the Midnight Library, I grew increasingly annoyed by her inability to feel happy regardless of her circumstances — even when achieving tremendous success or engaging in meaningful work. While the answer was obviously staring her in the face (that true happiness comes from within), she continued to superficially hop through life after life. With so much telling and very little showing, the novel eventually became a chore to read.

On a personal note, the book did make me appreciate that I live my own life without regrets, even when my circumstances were (or are) terrible. I have stayed true to myself, made the best decisions I could with the information available, and persevered along my path. Another book I read recently claimed that happiness is knowing “enough” without constantly moving the goalposts. Living authentically for my dreams and striving toward that vision without needing more than enough has indeed been my way of life. I’m happily alive. I am glad Nora eventually found that truth for herself.

Rating: 3/5

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *